- AI
Tobi Lutke's AI Foresight: Why Shopify's 'Call to Tinker' is a Masterclass for Innovative Leaders
"What we have learned so far is that using AI well is a skill that needs to be carefully learned by… using it a lot. It’s just too unlike everything else. The call to tinker with it was the right one, but it was too much of a suggestion. This is what I want to change here today. We also learned that, as opposed to most tools, AI acts as a multiplier." Tobi Lutke, Shopify CEO
Tobi Lutke’s AI Foresight: Why Shopify’s ‘Call to Tinker’ is a Masterclass for Innovative Leaders
The recent leak (and subsequent official sharing) of an internal Shopify memo by CEO Tobi Lutke sent ripples through the tech and business communities. While the memo’s core message – that “Reflexive AI usage is now a baseline expectation at Shopify” – is striking, the real masterclass lies in the journey that preceded this mandate. Lutke didn’t just flip a switch; he cultivated AI readiness through foresight, empowerment, and a crucial early phase of encouraged experimentation. For founders and leaders aiming to build resilient, future-proof businesses, there are powerful lessons here.
The Power of Encouraged Experimentation: Setting the Stage
Long before AI became a mandatory skill, Lutke championed exploration. He recalls the Shopify Summit 2024 talk, created using AI agents, as “a call to action and invitation for everyone to tinker with AI, to dispel any scepticism or confusion.” This wasn’t just lip service; Shopify provided tools like chat.shopify.io, Copilot, Cursor, and Claude code, empowering employees at all levels to experiment.
This “call to tinker” achieved several critical things:
- Demystified AI: It moved AI from an abstract concept to a tangible tool employees could interact with daily, whatever their hierarchical position.
- Built Foundational Skills: As Lutke notes, “using AI well is a skill that needs to be carefully learned by… using it a lot.” The tinkering phase allowed individuals to develop prompting skills and understand AI’s capabilities and limitations organically.
- Identified Early Adopters & Use Cases: It naturally surfaced individuals and teams who intuitively grasped AI’s potential and began applying it to real-world problems, sharing their findings in internal channels.
- Cultivated a Learning Culture: It reinforced Shopify’s core values of being a “Constant Learner” and “Thriving on Change,” making the eventual mandate less of a shock and more of a natural progression.
From Tinkering to Integration: Why It Matters Now
The memo signifies a shift from encouraged exploration to strategic necessity. Lutke is clear: AI is a “multiplier,” capable of turning high-performers into “100X” contributors by enabling them to tackle previously “implausible tasks.” This isn’t just about individual productivity; it’s about organizational capability and competitive advantage.
Key takeaways from Shopify’s transition apply broadly:
- AI as an Operational Lever: Integrating AI isn’t just a tech initiative; it’s becoming fundamental to operational efficiency and scaling. Lutke explicitly links it to the GSD (Get Stuff Done) framework and performance reviews.
- Pragmatism Over Hype: The requirement for teams to justify not using AI before requesting more resources forces a practical, ROI-driven assessment of its potential. It cuts through the noise and focuses on tangible benefits.
- Top-Down and Bottom-Up: While the mandate comes from the top, it builds upon the foundation laid by widespread, bottom-up experimentation. This dual approach is crucial for successful adoption.
Architecting Your Own AI Journey
Shopify’s journey provides a valuable blueprint. Simply mandating AI usage without laying the groundwork is unlikely to succeed. Cultivating readiness involves:
- Providing Access & Encouraging Play: Give your teams the tools and the psychological safety to experiment without immediate pressure for results.
- Fostering Knowledge Sharing: Create channels for sharing successes, failures, and interesting prompts, as Shopify did with Slack and Vault.
- Leading by Example: Leaders demonstrating their own use of AI (like Lutke) sends a powerful message.
- Strategic Integration: Once foundational skills are developing, think about how AI can be woven into core processes – product development, financial planning, operational workflows – to solve specific business challenges.
The Takeaway
Tobi Lutke’s foresight in encouraging early AI experimentation paved the way for its deeper strategic integration at Shopify. His approach demonstrates that building AI capability isn’t just about acquiring technology; it’s about cultivating a mindset and skillset across the organization. For any leader looking to leverage AI not just as a buzzword but as a genuine engine for growth and innovation, Shopify’s journey from “tinkering” to “baseline expectation” offers a compelling case study in pragmatic, forward-thinking leadership.
Trapped in the Scaling Paradox? Let's Engineer Your Breakthrough
You've built something valuable, but now face the scaling paradox: success creates the very chaos that prevents further growth. Your operations strain, financial visibility blurs, and technology becomes a bottleneck rather than an accelerator. I've guided dozens of founders beyond this critical juncture by integrating battle-tested operational frameworks, financial clarity tools, and pragmatic AI solutions. Book a no-obligation 30-minute diagnostic call to pinpoint your specific scaling levers and outline a concrete path forward.
Years in the Scaling Trenches
Not just advising, but personally building and scaling ventures through the same complexity you face today.
Revenue Unlocked Through Strategic Scaling
Measurable growth achieved by implementing integrated operational, financial, and technology frameworks.
Complex Portfolio Growth Engineered
Proven expertise in strategic asset growth and complex portfolio management applying the same scaling principles I bring to your venture.